A college professor writes the below, in support of Rod Dreher and the larger value of the Benedict Option, which is the strategic (not wholesale!) withdrawal of Christians from secular culture. There’s lots to his defense, which is a response to common Benedict Option criticisms, but this I think is particularly important as a reason opponents of the Benedict Option are naive:

A complacency about the state of the church. It’s bad enough that Ryn et al. are willfully blind to how bad things are out in the world and how things have failed. They also think things are hunky-dory in the church or at least their own part of it. Well, sorry to say, the evidence is strongly to the contrary. Sunday-morning-only feel-good MTD is no match for our culture. Sure, at the end of the day the Ben Op boils down to “Be the Church,” but we are so, so, so far from the world of the Tipi Loschi and the monks of Norcia yet oblivious to how poorly it is going and how much more interior work we have to do. Your alarmism is far preferable to their complacency. That is not just for monastics, but for all believers.

We all need to be far more intentional about our spiritual life, and far more dedicated to building community and planning for the Flood that is upon us, daubing our arks with pitch and preparing to stay afloat.

This is where I think you need to be more overt: the Ben Op is indeed a shift in emphasis, in tone, in focus, and in energy. Sure, fight some public battles. But check out of the culture far more, care about the politics far less, direct our time, talent, and treasures far more to religious and cultural matters than political ones. Some inward turn is necessary, and our outward turn should be more about religious witness and missionary activity than straight politics, and our straight politics should be more about religious liberty than anything else.

I think that checking out of the culture far more than most of us do is terribly important. People of Ryn’s age have no clue how badly their own grandchildren and nephews and nieces are being formed by it, and how that is the most immediate threat–we have met the enemy and he is us.